Great effort but could use more improvement

While I appreciate the environmentally friendly concept of the packaging, I found it to be inconvenient in practice. Having to push the product back into the tube with my fingers isn’t something I’m comfortable with, especially when on the go.

The shade “Fireside Temptation” didn’t quite work for me, and the formula felt a bit too drying for use as a lip tint. However, it performs decently as a cheek tint, though it’s not smudge-proof, which might be an issue for those with oily skin or a busy day ahead.

I admire the sustainable approach, but the functionality of the packaging and the formula’s hydration levels could use some improvement. If these aspects are addressed, this product has great potential!

- Product gifted by Birch Babe.